SO MUCH GOOD BLOG
somuchgood
•

There’s a sentence I’m hearing more often in strategic planning sessions, usually somewhere between a discussion about slow membership growth and a review of the marketing budget:
“If we just educated people on what we have.”
I understand where it comes from. You know the credit union has good people, competitive products, and a mission worth supporting. It’s frustrating to watch members borrow somewhere else or send their paycheck to another institution when you believe you could serve them better.
But that sentence hides an assumption that is killing progress before it starts: If people understood us, they would choose us.
What if they already understand enough to make their decision? What if the product doesn’t fit their life, the technology makes things harder, or the way we deliver service asks more of them than they’re willing to give?
Imagine someone saying, “People aren’t using the phone book anymore. We just need to teach them how to use it.”
We could produce a lovely tutorial. Explain alphabetical order. Highlight the yellow pages. Send a series of emails about all those useful numbers.
Meanwhile, the person we’re trying to educate has already found the number, checked the business hours, read the reviews, and gotten directions on their phone.
They don’t need a better explanation of the phone book. They have a better way to accomplish what they came to do.
That possibility deserves a place in your next board discussion.
Having it and making it useful are different things
A credit union can have mobile banking and still offer a frustrating mobile experience. It can offer online account opening that eventually requires a branch visit during someone’s workday. It can advertise personal service while sending a member through three departments to get an answer.
From inside the building, we see a list of capabilities. From outside, people experience the time, effort, uncertainty, and expense involved in getting something done.
The FDIC’s 2023 household survey found that 48.3% of banked households used mobile banking as their primary way to access their accounts, up from 5.5% in 2013. That shift makes the quality of the everyday digital experience a serious strategic question. “We have an app” is the beginning of the conversation. Is it a useful app that doesn’t create friction?
The same survey found that 49.7% of all households used nonbank online payment services such as PayPal, Venmo, or Cash App. That doesn’t mean they abandoned their bank or credit union. It does mean their financial lives can involve several providers. Membership alone doesn’t tell us which parts of that life we’ve earned.
There’s also evidence that awareness matters. In J.D. Power’s 2025 U.S. Retail Banking Satisfaction Study, customers aware of their bank’s financial health tools and supportive services scored satisfaction 96 points higher, on average, than customers who weren’t aware. That’s an association, not proof that an education campaign caused the difference. But it’s a useful reminder: helping people discover something valuable can make a difference.
The question is whether we’ve established that what we’re explaining is valuable to the people we want to reach. That is the most important discussion to be having right now.
Before approving another campaign
We don’t need to redesign an application or select every digital feature. We do need to ask questions that force a better diagnosis. Here are five I’d put on the table to start the conversation:
1. What evidence tells us this is an awareness problem?
“Members don’t know” should be a hypothesis we test. Ask people who borrowed elsewhere whether they knew you offered the loan. Then ask why they chose another lender. The answer might be awareness. It might also be speed, eligibility, convenience, a better payment, or an experience they trusted more.
Surveying only your most engaged members won’t give you the whole picture. Include members who barely use you, recent departures, and people in your field of membership who have never joined. Ask about an actual recent decision rather than whether they might consider you someday.
2. What are people trying to accomplish, and how well do we fit?
People want to replace a broken car, get through an expensive month, pay someone back, or understand whether they can afford a home. A product name means very little until it connects to that need. “WIIFM: What’s in it for me!”
Consider someone paid every other Friday whose loan payment is due on a fixed date that never lines up comfortably. Explaining the loan more often won’t change the mismatch. A payment schedule that fits their paycheck might. That’s a conversation for lending and operations as much as marketing.
3. Where do interested people get stuck?
Ask leadership to show the journey from first interest to completed account or funded loan. How many start? How many finish? Where do they leave? How long does follow-up take?
Then experience it yourselves. Try the process on a phone. Submit an inquiry. Ask a question that requires help. Compare that experience with the alternatives your prospective members actually use.
A campaign can generate interest while a slow response or confusing application loses it. If we only review clicks and new accounts, we may miss everything happening between them. How many marketing dollars are wasted on people who try to apply, but never finish because of the friction?
4. Why would someone go through the trouble of choosing us?
Moving direct deposit, recurring payments, and everyday banking takes effort. “We’re friendly” may be true, but is that enough to make the move worthwhile?
Ask for a specific answer: For whom are we a better choice, in what situation, and why? Then ask what we do to make switching easier. A compelling benefit and practical help making the change belong together.
5. What are we willing to change when the answer is uncomfortable?
Research has little value if every finding leads to the same instruction: Have marketing explain it better.
Sometimes the right response will be clearer communication. Sometimes it will be fewer steps, faster decisions, different service hours, a better product, or staff with the authority to solve a problem.
The board’s role is to expect a plan with ownership, resources, and measurable outcomes. Leadership’s role is to carry that plan across departments. Growth needs more than a marketing assignment.
Perspective before prescription
This is why So Much Good begins a relationship by gaining perspective before proposing solutions.
Our onboarding brings leadership, marketing, and the people responsible for operations, lending, and digital service into the conversation. We explore who the credit union is best designed to serve, where growth gets stuck, and what marketing is being asked to fix. Surveys, secret shopping, and market research help us compare internal beliefs with the experience people actually have.
One of the most useful questions in that process is simple: What feels harder than it should?
The goal is to identify the obstacles that matter most and agree on what must change. A larger advertising budget may make sense. So may fixing the experience before inviting more people into it.
That work matters because our mission is to help prevent unnecessary credit union mergers. Long-term independence depends in part on continuing to earn a meaningful place in people’s lives. A proud history and good intentions deserve a future. Relevance helps make that future possible.
At your next planning session, when someone says, “We just need to educate our members on what we have,” stay curious a little longer.
Ask what members know. Ask what they need. Ask what they experience. Ask why they chose someone else.
Then consider the question that might change the entire conversation:
If everyone understood exactly what we offer and how it works, would they choose us?
Before we teach another class on the phone book, let’s make sure we’re offering something people still want to use.





